Home/Articles/NFL
NFL·June 12, 2026 05:16 AM ET

NFL Draft Discrepancy: Jimmy Johnson Chart vs. Actual Player Outcomes

Analysis shows Pick 32 is significantly undervalued.

Wire Report IntelligenceUpdated Jun 121 min read
Post on X
NFL

What happened: A new analysis of the NFL Draft's trade value standards reveals a significant gap between theoretical points and actual player performance. While the traditional model created by Jimmy Johnson suggests the first overall pick is five times more valuable than pick 32, historical outcomes indicate the value gap is much narrower.

Why it matters: Front offices often overpay to move into the top five despite high variance in top-tier outcomes. Data shows that 75% of top-10 selections never earn an All-Pro nod, suggesting that holding multiple late first-round picks may offer better value than a single high-end gamble.

By the numbers: Actual Outcome (40-65% value).

What to watch: Expect analytical front offices to increasingly favor trading down to capitalize on the surplus value of late first-round selections.

Sources

More NFL news

CONVERSATION
Loading comments…
NFLAnalysis
Follow NFL Intelligence
Real-time signals and analysis
@WireReportNFL
WR Pro
The day's sports, briefed to your inbox at 7am ET. Every claim sourced.
$9/monthFree weekly newsletter →
RELATED STORIES
← Back to Wire Report