Home/Articles/NFL
NFL·ANALYSIS·October 22, 2026 01:10 PM ET

John Harbaugh turns to J.J. McCarthy as Giants' third starting quarterback

Jaxson Dart went on injured reserve Sept. 24 after surgery.

Wire Report IntelligenceUpdated 50m1 min read
Post on X
This explains John Harbaugh’s rationale in starting a third different QB. J.J. McCarthy provides athleticism and mobilit Via @WerderEdNFL on X

What happened: Per Ed Werder, McCarthy provides the athleticism and movement skills the New York Giants have lacked at the position without Dart. Matt Nagy said via Jordan Raanan that McCarthy's skill set closely resembles Dart's, restoring a substantial portion of the offensive playbook.

Why it matters: The quarterback switch follows weeks of evaluation after Harbaugh first left the door open for a McCarthy start on Oct. 2, days after consulting his brother Jim Harbaugh before acquiring the 2024 first-round pick. Aligning the starter's dual-threat profile with the original offensive scheme spares the coaching staff from overhauling the system midseason.

What to watch: Focus now shifts to how much of the designed movement game New York deploys in McCarthy's first test leading the starting offense.

Sources

CONVERSATION
Loading comments…
NFLAnalysisNew York GiantsJ.J. McCarthyJaxson Dart
Follow NFL Intelligence
Real-time signals and analysis
@WireReportNFL
WR Pro
The day's sports, briefed to your inbox at 7am ET. Every claim sourced.
$9/monthFree weekly newsletter →
RELATED STORIES
← Back to Wire Report