What happened: Charlie O'Connor first detailed the proposed one-for-one deal in January 2024, after Gauthier declined to sign with Philadelphia. The Canadiens retained the selection and used it on David Reinbacher.
Why it matters: The decision carries fresh weight with Gauthier unsigned entering the 2026-27 offseason. He reportedly rejected a four-year offer worth $13 million annually, sharpening the contrast between retaining a premium pick and paying for established scoring.
By the numbers: Gauthier produced 41 goals and 69 points across 76 games in 2025-26. The reported contract offer totaled $52 million over four years.
What to watch: Gauthier's contract negotiations and Reinbacher's 2026-27 role will continue shaping assessments of Montreal's decision.