What happened: National debate surrounds Jonathan Taylor as analysts evaluate his standing among the league's premier offensive weapons. Selected out of Wisconsin in the 2020 NFL Draft, he has spent his career shouldering a primary backfield role.

Why it matters: During the 2025 campaign, Taylor generated 1,585 rushing yards and reached the end zone 18 times for the Colts. Producing elite scoring output alongside heavy touch volume separates him from modern committee backfields. That proven durability and red-zone efficiency solidify his place at the top of the position.